Thanks to our fans on Facebook for providing such enthusiastic responses to my casual question about who’s got the best Italian beef sandwich in Chicago. There were so many comments, I had to write about it.—Chris “The Bull” Garlington
Dave can tell you: even after living in Chicago ten years, I did not know Italian beef sandwiches were invented in Chicago. I thought they were, well, Italian, kapisch? When we were writing a sidebar for our book that listed all the great foods invented in the
Windy City, I argued for a good half an hour that Italian beef sandwiches were from the papal boot. Allow me to state publicly: Dave, you were right and I was wrong.
The Italian Beef sandwich is as Chicago as Al Capone; that’s an argument that’s been put to bed. Who makes the best Italian beef sandwiches in town? That’s an argument that will last forever. Until then, our fans have weighed in, gone a couple of rounds, and come up with a list of the best places to get a real, authentic, original, classic Chicago Italian beef sandwich.
However; in order for this to make sense, a definition:
- An Italian beef sandwich is: a crispy, split, Italian bun,
over-filled with a wad of spiced, marinated,slow-cooked beef slicedpaper-thin , drunk in it’s own au jus. Green or hot peppers mixed into the meat is a typical option. An Italian beef sandwich should be served with so much gravy the customer is forced into making a critical split second decision: should I pick it up, or eat it with a spoon? - Cheese is optional. However, should you choose cheese, choose wisely: Smoked Gouda, Havarti, Osu Eraty, Pepper Jack, and Cheddar are all nice in their places but their place is NOT melted onto an Italian. Provolone, pal, and only provolone. Mozzarella in a pinch—and don’t admit it.
- Asiago dusted olive embedded artisan breads are cute when you’re on a date but using it to dress up an Italian it’s like wearing a tuxedo to a baseball game. Cheap bread. Local, sure—but cheap with crispy, crackly, crumbs exploding in all directions: a
soaking-up-gravy-like-a -^%$#@!-sponge white bread. No substitutes!
That’s an Italian sandwich. We’ll post a review each day for a week until we reveal the number 1 Italian beef joint in the City of Big Shoulders.
And then you can argue.




Scanner chatter: